Hill, Moreno blame delays for missed Clarity Act window but differ on reach of agency rulemaking

RWA Signal Insight
InfrastructureRep. French Hill and Sen. Bernie Moreno recently addressed the legislative failure of the Clarity Act, which stalled in the Senate after passing the House in September 2026. The lawmakers expressed regret over the missed opportunity to bundle the Clarity Act with the GENIUS Act, noting that legislative momentum was lost due to excessive bill complexity and political friction. While Hill maintains that only formal legislation can provide the permanent legal certainty required for the digital asset market, Moreno suggests that the SEC and CFTC could independently establish up to 80% of a functional regulatory framework through rigorous rulemaking. Both officials expressed skepticism regarding any progress during the current lame-duck session, effectively pushing major market structure reforms into the future. This regulatory impasse remains a critical bottleneck for the RWA sector, as the lack of clear, codified rules complicates the institutional adoption of tokenized assets. The ongoing debate highlights the tension between relying on agency-led enforcement versus comprehensive congressional action to define the legal status of digital securities. Ultimately, the absence of a unified framework leaves market participants navigating a landscape defined by litigation risk rather than statutory clarity.
Key points
- Clarity Act failed to pass the Senate after stalling in September 2026.
- Sen. Moreno suggests regulators could implement 80% of a framework via rulemaking.
- Rep. Hill argues agency actions lack the permanence of formal congressional legislation.
- Lawmakers see zero chance for digital asset legislation during the lame-duck session.
Background
The Clarity Act and GENIUS Act are proposed legislative frameworks intended to establish comprehensive market structure rules for digital assets in the United States. These bills aim to clarify the jurisdictional boundaries between the SEC and CFTC, providing a legal foundation for the issuance and trading of tokenized real-world assets. Without such legislation, the industry currently operates under a patchwork of enforcement actions and evolving agency interpretations.